Rene Liu,
Huang Lei,
Yin Chiao-the,
Li-jen Tai,
Ah Lei Gua
... see more
A woman discovers unexpected rivals for the affections of her fiancée in this drama from Taiwan set in the 1930s and 1940s. Hsu Shaodong (Huang Lei) is a gifted classical musician who is pledged to ma... read more
DVD Release Date: May 8, 2003
Stats: 16 reviews
Your Rating
Flixster Reviews (16)
No featured reviews yet. Help by rating our reviews.
Critic Reviews
An overwrought Taiwanese soaper about three people and their mixed-up relationship.
An exquisite love story directed with admirable subtlety and sensitivity by Li-kong Hsu and Chi Yin from a superb script by Hui-ling Wang and Ming-xia Wang. Full Review
This dreadfully earnest inversion of the Concubine love triangle eschews the previous film's historical panorama and roiling pathos for bug-eyed mugging and gay-niche condescension. Full Review
It's a square, sentimental drama that satisfies, as comfort food often can. Full Review
[Lin Chung's] voice is rather unexceptional, even irritating (at least to this Western ear), making it awfully hard to buy the impetus for the complicated love triangle that develops between the three... Full Review
[Liu's] artistry deepens here, as Ing'er grows from overeager girl to knowing woman, one whose dilemma is as vexing as any she heard sung from the stage of her father's opera house. Full Review
The film makes a tragic error by going on for too long, trying to mirror every subsequent event in Chinese history: war, revolution, Communism, etc. Full Review
The film has the courage of its convictions and excellent performances on its side. Full Review
Critic ratings and reviews powered by RottenTomatoes.com
Fresh (60% or more critics rated the movie positively)
Rotten (59% or fewer critics rated the movie positively)


