The Garden Murder Case (1936)

Edmund Lowe, Virginia Bruce, Gene Lockhart, Benita Hume, Nat Pendleton ... see more  , Grant Mitchell , Henry B. Walthall , H.B. Warner , Charles Trowbridge , Douglas Walton , Kent Smith , Frieda Inescort , Etienne Girardot , Rosalind Ivan , Jessie Ralph , William Austin

Edmund Lowe made his only screen appearance as S. S. Van Dine's dilettante sleuth Philo Vance in The Garden Murder Case. The story wastes no time getting started, with Floyd Garden (Douglas Walton) be... read more ing killed in the first reel from a fall in a steeplechase. It looks like an accident -- but then, so do the subsequent deaths of Lowe Hammle (Gene Lockhart) and Mrs. Fenwick-Ralston (Frieda Inescourt). The police are baffled, but Philo Vance (Lowe) deduces that the victims were done in by a very clever -- and very deadly -- hypnotist. The revelation of the killer's identity won't be surprising to longtime mystery buffs, but it proved quite a shock to audiences in 1936. The tense final scene, in which the murder attempts to mesmerize Vance into committing suicide, was effective enough to be "borrowed" for the 1946 Sherlock Holmes film The Woman in Green. ~ Hal Erickson, Rovi