Oranges And Sunshine (2011)

None yet... Got one?

• 
  
  December 9, 2011

  SirPant

  Oranges & Sunshine is a very impressive debut feature, looks like it runs in the family as Jim Loach seems to be a chip off the old block. I very glad to hear it too, although this film isn't in the same style as one of his fathers, it's as good as one of his and it has the heart... read more of one. I don't think I've ever seen a bad Emily Watson performance, here she cements herself in being one of my all time favourite actresses and is surrounded by a competent cast. I did know of the story and its eventual conclusion; the apology from the British government just over a year ago, but that doesn't stop the climax and the minutes leading to it from being some of the most tense and thrilling in resent years. In fact, the last film that gave me tingles like this was Route Irish - Ken Loach's last film! With two Loachs working today, cinema just got that little bit better!

  Share This Review
• 
  
  September 19, 2011

  mumby1988

  There have been a number of young directors coming through recently who have gained attention not just through their talents but through the reputation of their fathers. We have Nicolas Winding Refn, son of acclaimed editor Anders Refn, whose recent feature Drive could translate ... read morehis cult status in Europe into mainstream popularity. We have Rowan Joffe, son of The Mission's Roland Joffe, whose remake of Brighton Rock contains moments of future promise. And now we have Jim Loach, son of Ken, who has delivered one of the best films of the year with Oranges and Sunshine.
  
  Oranges and Sunshine is a biographical drama based on the life and work of Margaret Humphreys, a social worker based in Nottingham in the mid-1980s. In 1986 she came into contact with an Australian woman trying to trace her parents, and through her investigations uncovered the Home Children programme which had been pursued by the British, Australian and Canadian governments for over a hundred years up to the 1970s. The programme was based on the notion that it was cheaper to care for orphans by sending them to Australia than it was to keep them in Britain, leading thousands to be rounded up and sent off to what they were told was a better life.
  
  Like his father's best work, Oranges and Sunshine finds Jim Loach marrying gripping and contentious political issues to very well-written character drama. This is not an Oscar-baiting film which bends over backwards to convince us that Margaret Humphreys is a saint and what she is doing is incredibly worthy. We do not have to be lectured about how important the subject matter is: its extraordinary and at times shocking nature emerges naturally and powerfully, as a result of deeply empathising with the characters.
  
  The character construction in Oranges and Sunshine is comprehensive and yet completely unforced, thanks to a wonderful screenplay by Rona Munro. Emily Watson, whom I once described as "the go-to actress for delicate, sensitive female characters", turns in another remarkable performance as Margaret Humphreys. Her character is relentless in pursuing her goal - not justice, or revenge, but catharsis for the people involved. But the film doesn't portray her in an entirely rose-tinted way; we see the effect that her selfless crusade is having, whether on her marriage, her health or her reputation.
  
  Over the course of the film, Watson's character finds her existing principles as a social worker coming into conflict with both the physical and emotional demands of her new line of work. She has spent her life trying to keep a distance between herself and her subjects, adamantly declining to share in their most personal moments. But the more her work uncovers, the more she becomes an integral part of what is unfolding, as both a spokesman of the Home Children and increasingly as their friend. In an understated and naturalistic way, the film explores how people are changed, often against their will, by their dedication towards a cause, to the point at which it becomes their life's calling.
  
  Watson is ably supported by two brilliant members of the supporting cast. Hugo Weaving as terrific as Jack, one of the first people Humphreys take on board to try and find his mother. Every time he is on screen, our heart leaps at the merest hint of a smile from underneath that huge brown beard. He is someone who has been hurt deeply in the past, and after all this time of repressing or forgetting, he genuinely wants to reach out and connect. It's a very busy performance, with lots of hand gestures and fidgeting, but it feels completely genuine.
  
  The other great performance comes from David Wenham, who worked with Watson six years ago on The Proposition. There is an obstinate air about Len, a sense of distance and denial; when we first meet him, we think that he might be some kind of government mole, attempting to infiltrate and snare Humphreys. But he emerges as someone of immense loyalty who is difficult but self-effacing. His first meeting with his mother isn't shown on screen, but his expression would lead us to think that it was as difficult as he was.
  
  Wenham's character also gets one of the most moving lines in the film. After they have taken tea with the brothers at Bin Doon (more on that later), Margaret asks him about how he feels and why he can't open up emotionally. Len replies: "I had to stop crying when I was eight. I wouldn't know how to start now." It's a beautiful line which conveys so much about the trauma of these people, whose whole identity has been called into question.
  
  Even in its most serious moments, you could call Oranges and Sunshine a tear-jerker, because it is impossible not to show emotion at the plight of these men and women. Certain sections feel like a documentary, with a montage of individuals candidly talking about their experiences with the Christian Brothers or working on farms. One man talks about being repeatedly beaten; another recounts a gruesome incident of rape; another still remembering being told that he had "a lovely singing voice", a comment which led to him being castrated. These scenes are shocking, harrowing and heart-breaking, causing us to seethe with anger at what happened but also weep for what these men went through.
  
  There are also several scenes in Oranges and Sunshine which are very frightening. On two occasions Margaret's base in Australia is attacked by masked men working for the Christian Brothers - they attempt to break into her house, throwing bricks and calling her everything under the sun. But more terrifying is the deeply uncomfortable sequence in the dining hall at Bin Doon. Margaret is taken by Len to eat with the priests, many of whom were personally involved in the abuses detailed in the film. There is a very awkward silence while Len goes to make some tea, before Margaret finally plucks up the courage to speak. When she does, it is not to condemn or make small talk: she simply asks if they are afraid of her, and if so, why?
  
  In terms of its subject matter and approach, the film is an interesting companion piece to Rabbit-Proof Fence, Philip Noyce's docudrama about the relocation and Christianisation of aborigines. Both films take very dim views of the governments involved, or at least dispute the moral reasoning behind the decisions they made. But more importantly, both films have their political analyses rooted in the emotions and extraordinary acts of ordinary people. Margaret's meetings with government officials in Oranges and Sunshine are comparable to Kenneth Branagh's scenes in Rabbit-Proof Fence; the film is attacking what these individuals stand for, but it doesn't demean them by refusing to consider or depict their human nature.
  
  The film is beautifully shot by Denson Baker, who fills the screen with lots of watery, shimmering blues to underscore both the beauty of the landscape and the inherent melancholy of the stories taking place in it. Loach's camerawork is adept and subtle, getting in close to the characters when it needs to but allowing the wide shots to breathe. The film captures the period settings very well, particularly the faded streets of 1980s Britain. And all of these visual elements are elevated by the score from Lisa Gerrard, who worked with Hans Zimmer on Gladiator. There is a further comparison here with Rabbit-Proof Fence, whose soundtrack featured Peter Gabriel and The Blind Boys of Alabama; both films bring raw yet ethereal tones to the arid landscapes of Australia.
  
  Oranges and Sunshine is an impressive and powerful debut from Jim Loach, who has inherited much of his father's gift for moving, honest and vulnerable filmmaking. Its opening section is a little slow and conventional, but after a shaky start it never misses a beat, refusing to flinch from the most difficult aspects of its subject matter. Unlike Sarah's Key, it also refuses to tip over into melodrama as the more familial elements encroach towards the end. But its biggest achievement is to convincingly and understatedly marry politics and drama together, creating a film of great quality which will break your heart.

  Share This Review
• 
  
  July 8, 2011

  c0up

  'Oranges and Sunshine'. Emily Watson brilliant as an unduly guilt burdened, relentlessly driven woman, trying to write the wrongs of the 100,000+ kids involved in the organised deportation between the U.K. and Australian governments, bringing them some level of closure and connec... read moretion to their families.
  
  Moving, and revealing a part of history I wasn't previously aware of, with commendable supporting performances from Hugo Weaving and David Wenham.

  Share This Review
• 
  
  November 15, 2011

  gator681

  In "Oranges and Sunshine," Margaret Humphreys(Emily Watson) is a social worker in Nottingham, England in 1986 who is first seen in assisting in taking a baby away from a mother unable to care for her. One night after a group therapy session, she is accosted by a woman who claime... read mored to be deported to Australia when she was a child and is now seeking her birth mother. Some time later, Margaret hears a similar story from a woman trying to contact her brother who was sent to Australia at about the same time. Thinking they may not be exactly isolated cases, she contacts Australia House for information which she does not receive but does instead get confirmation which is almost as valuable. With the support of her husband Merv(Richard Dillane), the next stop for Margaret is Australia.
  
  Written by Rona Munro and directed by Jim Loach, "Oranges and Sunshine" may be a little rough around the edges but still packs a wallop in depicting a real life tragedy. The movie does not take the easy way out by showing the reunions and the emotional climax is satisfying in a subtle way, as we are not sure what is going on at first. As the final credits reveal, there were about 130,000 children involved in the deportation which went on to 1970.(According to one account I read, white Australians were afraid of being outnumbered by Aborigines.) Where the movie excels in the place of a potential documentary is in telling the personal stories of heartbreak of those deported who were victimized not only by separation but also from abuse.(And Hugo Weaving is superb in playing one of the grown men.) Margaret is deeply touched by those she encounters as she undergoes an emotional journey which is never easy and still continues to the present day. Along the way, she learns she is not alone and becomes a part of a much larger family while receiving support from her own.

  Share This Review
• 
  
  June 16, 2011

  panta2

  I needed three days to write this review... Jim Loach's sombre, painful film hit me really hard, much harder than you'd expect from the soft-focus poster.
  
  This eye-opening film looks back from the viewpoint of the late 1980s at the forced migration of children in care from Br... read moreitain to Australia in the '40s, '50s and '60s - a bitter journey sugared by the promises of this film's title. The worst thing is that the parents of many kids were told that their offspring had been adopted, while the kids were sometimes shipped to abusive institutions and told they were orphans. The Australian and British governments brought this shameful episode in their histories to something of a close in 2009 and 2010 when first Kevin Rudd and then Gordon Brown offered official apologies to the child migrants... too late, though!
  
  Emily Watson plays Margaret Humphreys, a Nottingham social worker who made it her mission in the 1980s to investigate the post-war scandal of child deportation. She is shocked to discover that children in care were literally transported - like criminals from a bygone age - to Australia, there to be kept in children's homes. Many were abused in places run by the Christian Brothers in the remote bush - particularly in a place called Bindoon, south of Perth. In the burning sun, Bindoon looks like something akin to Castle Dracula.
  
  Jim Loach's film shows how Humphreys' controversial intervention triggered something like the retrieval of a repressed collective memory. And audience could feel the scars of all of that! There are excellent performances from Watson, from Hugo Weaving as a gentle, damaged soul and David Wenham, a truculent ex-Bindoon boy who makes an unlikely common cause with Humphreys. This is hard to watch but it is a history lesson to be remembered - it comes by courtesy of the "civilized society" fighting for the "freedom in the world"!

  Share This Review
• 
  
  January 28, 2012

  robfearon

  Honourable mention: one of the worst films of 2011.

  Share This Review

• Hugo Weaving as Jack
• David Wenham as Len
• Aisling Loftus as Susie
• Stuart Wolfenden as Bill
• Lorraine Ashbourne as Nicky
• Molly Windsor as Rachel
• Federay Holmes as Charlotte
• Richard Dillane as Merv
• Alistair Cummings as Australia House Official

Click a thumb to vote on that suggestion, or add your own suggestions.

• 
  Slumdog Millionaire (93%)
• 
  Dust (100%)
• 
  Amazing Grace (100%)

• • Margaret Humphreys: Were talking about the organized deportation of children.
• • Jack: How would you like to go to Australia? The sun shines everyday... you pick oranges off the trees for your breakfast.

No quizzes for Oranges And Sunshine. Want to create one?

• Oranges And Sunshine: Beach
• Oranges And Sunshine: Park, Everyone Has A Mother
• Oranges And Sunshine: Australia House
• Oranges And Sunshine (Uk)
• Oranges And Sunshine: Washing Dishes

None yet...

No recent headlines. Got one?

• 

  To see

  by jma377
  32 Movies
• 

  2011 Top Ten

  by mattpromo
  10 Movies
• 

  Showcase 2012

  by tsingchie
  62 Movies
• 

  GTA 2011 Limited

  by tim930
  433 Movies
• 

  NothingElseToWatch

  by diogomendonca
  39 Movies

No skins yet. Interested in creating one?